Legal Implications of the Merauke Food Estate: A Critical Analysis of Customary Rights and Environmental Concerns

Finda Pratiwi Yuwono

doi:10.58829/lp.11.2.2024.294-317

Authors

Finda Pratiwi Yuwono Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.58829/lp.11.2.2024.294-317

Keywords:

Food Estate, FPIC, Customary Rights, Environmental Impact, Conflict Resolution

Abstract

The Food Estate program in Merauke, part of Indonesia's National Strategic Project (PSN), aims to enhance food security through large-scale land management. However, its implementation has faced significant criticism for disregarding the Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) principle, leading to violations of the rights of Indigenous Peoples and severe environmental degradation, including extensive deforestation. The involvement of military personnel in facilitating the program further complicates the situation, drawing international scrutiny, particularly in light of Indonesia's participation in COP29. This study employs a normative legal research method with a qualitative approach, analyzing secondary data from various sources, including laws, regulations, books, journals, and online resources. The findings reveal that the Merauke Food Estate program exhibits substantial flaws in planning and execution, neglecting sustainable development principles and the FPIC standard. The study also suggests that conflict resolution mechanisms, such as class action lawsuits, could be a viable solution, provided these processes are grounded in FPIC principles and actively involve MHA to ensure equitable outcomes for affected communities.

References

Al Fikri, Muhammad Ainurrasyid. "Implementation of strict liability by companies in cases of environmental damage in Indonesia: An overview of state administrative law in Indonesia." Indonesian State Law Review (ISLRev) 5, no. 2 (2022): 41-52.

Amiq, Bachrul, M. Syahrul Borman, Moh Taufik, Renda Aranggraeni, Pudji Astuti, Sukanya Aimim-Tham, and Aminah Aminah. "Environmental Damage: Community Lawsuit Against The Government Over Industrial Business Licenses." Law Reform 20, no. 1: 1-21.

Andrianto, Agus, Heru Komarudin, and Pablo Pacheco. "Expansion of oil palm plantations in Indonesia’s frontier: Problems of externalities and the future of local and indigenous communities." Land 8, no. 4 (2019): 56.

Anshari, Mulya, and Cahaya Permata. "Deforestasi Hutan Lindung dalam Proyek Strategis Nasional Food Estate: Perspektif Maqashid Syariah." Al Qalam: Jurnal Ilmiah Keagamaan dan Kemasyarakatan 18, no. 3 (2024): 2031-2047.

Aryo Bhawono, 2024, “Merauke Reject Half Bruised Because Food Estate”, Bethany, accessed on 28 October 2024, o'clock 16.23 WIB. https://betahita.id/news/detail/10633/merauke- refuses-to-be-beaten-by-food-estate.html?v=1729118191.

Brunet-Bélanger, Andréanne. "Bridging the Gap between Compliance and Translation: Unveiling the Challenges in fpic Enforcement in Paraguay." International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 1, no. aop (2025): 1-28.

Caldera, Cristobal Carmona. "Free Prior and Informed Consent in the Context of Extractive Projects in Indigenous Territory: General Rule and International Customary Law." Braz. J. Pub. Pol'y 9 (2019): 373.

Dewi, Rosita. "Gaining recognition through participatory mapping? The role of adat land in the implementation of the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate in Papua, Indonesia." ASEAS-Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies 9, no. 1 (2016): 87-105.

Dewi, Rosita. "Hijacking adat recognition through the establishment of new Customary Community Council in Papua, Indonesia." Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies 4, no. 3 (2017): 555-568.

Dieterle, Carolin. "When ‘best practice’means formalising: foreign large-scale land investments on customary tenure in Uganda and Sierra Leone." Review of International Political Economy (2025): 1-24.

Dwiartama, Angga, Zulfikar Ali Akbar, Rhino Ariefiansyah, Hendra Kurniawan Maury, and Sari Ramadhan. "Conservation, Livelihoods, and Agrifood Systems in Papua and Jambi, Indonesia: A Case for Diverse Economies." Sustainability 16, no. 5 (2024): 1996.

Elfitra, Elfitra, Afrizal Afrizal, and Zuldesni Zuldesni. "Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) as a Conflict Mitigation Instrument: FPIC Applicability for Mitigation of Structural Agrarian Conflicts in Indonesia." In International Conference on Social Sciences, Humanities, Economics and Law. European Alliance for Innovation (EAI), 2018.

Elizabeth, L. Yu, and Jeffrey B. Schwimmer. "Epidemiology of pediatric nonalcoholic fatty liver disease." Clinical liver disease 17, no. 3 (2021): 196-199.

Flemmer, Riccarda. "Contesting state monologues: Indigenous grassroots’ struggles with prior consultation norms in the Peruvian Amazon." International Studies Quarterly 67, no. 3 (2023): sqad068.

Ginting, Longgena, and Oliver Pye. "Resisting agribusiness development: The merauke integrated food and energy estate in West Papua, Indonesia." Advances in Southeast Asian Studies 6, no. 1 (2013): 160-182.

Hadiprayitno, Irene I. "Behind transformation: The right to food, agricultural modernisation and indigenous peoples in Papua, Indonesia." Human Rights Review 16 (2015): 123-141.

Hendra, Rahmad, Rosa Agustina, and Ratih Lestarini. "The Effects of Conflict and Palm Oil Investment Between Investors and Communities in Indonesia." International Journal of Environmental, Sustainability, and Social Science 4, no. 1 (2023): 142-152.

Indrawan, Mochamad, Julian Caldecott, and Ermayanti. "Mitigating tensions over land conversion in Papua, Indonesia." Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies 4, no. 1 (2017): 147-157.

Ito, Takeshi, Noer Fauzi Rachman, and Laksmi A. Savitri. "Power to make land dispossession acceptable: a policy discourse analysis of the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate (MIFEE), Papua, Indonesia." Journal of Peasant Studies 41, no. 1 (2014): 29-50.

Jiménez, Erick Guapizaca. "An Old Dilemma in Deep Seabed Mining: Free, Prior, and Informed Consent of Indigenous Peoples in Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction." AJIL Unbound 118 (2024): 83-87.

Kenney-Lazar, Miles, and Noboru Ishikawa. "Mega-plantations in Southeast Asia: Landscapes of displacement." Environment and Society 10, no. 1 (2019): 63-82.

Klein, Laurence, María Jesús Muñoz-Torres, and María Ángeles Fernández-Izquierdo. "Free, Prior, and Informed Consent: A Norm in Development or a Corporate Obligation?." International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 31, no. 5 (2024): 898-926.

Kurniawan, Nanang Indra, Indah Surya Wardhani, and Muhammad Djindan. "Oil Palm Plantation Expansion and Frontier-Making in Papua, Indonesia." In Local Responses to Global Challenges in Southeast Asia: A Transregional Studies Reader, pp. 315-335. 2023.

Kusniati, Retno. "Free, Prior, and Informed Consent Principles as Indigenous Peoples’ Right: Soft Law or Hard Law?." Jambe Law Journal 7, no. 1 (2024): 169-193.

Laitala, Kirsi, Ingun Grimstad Klepp, and Beverley Henry. "Does use matter? Comparison of environmental impacts of clothing based on fiber type." Sustainability 10, no. 7 (2018): 2524.

Larsen, Peter Bille, and Chantaly Chanthavisouk. "Free, prior, and informed consent, local officials, and changing biodiversity governance in Hin Nam No, Laos." Conservation Biology 38, no. 6 (2024): e14388.

Light, Sarah E. "The law of the corporation as environmental law." Stan. L. Rev. 71 (2019): 137.

Maftuchan, Ah. "Pemenuhan HAM dan Pembangunan Infrastruktur: Kajian Regulasi Proyek Strategis Nasional di Indonesia." Jurnal Hak Asasi Manusia 14, no. 14 (2018): 109-138.

McDonnell, John E. "The Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate (MIFEE): An Ecologically Induced Genocide of the Malind Anim." In The Genocide-Ecocide Nexus, pp. 102-123. Routledge, 2022.

Memah, Alisia Revalina. "Kajian Yuridis Gugatan Class Action Dalam Hukum Positif Di Indonesia." Lex Privatum 11, no. 3 (2023).

Mispansyah, Mispansyah, Nurunnisa Nurunnisa, Agus Mulyawan, and Muhammad Al Faqih. "Legal Policy of the National Food Granary Program (Food Estate) on Peat Land in Central Kalimantan Which Is Environmentally Investigent." International Journal Political, Law, and Social Science 4, no. 2 (2023).

Montambeault, Françoise, and Martin Papillon. "Repoliticising indigenous participation: FPIC protocols in Canada and Brazil." The International Journal of Human Rights 27, no. 2 (2023): 335-358.

Nwazi, Joseph. "Assessing the efficacy of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) in the settlement of environmental disputes in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria." Journal of Law and Conflict Resolution 9, no. 3 (2017): 26-41.

Obidzinski, Krystof, Ikuko Takahashi, Ahmad Dermawan, Heru Komarudin, and Agus Andrianto. "Can large scale land acquisition for agro-development in Indonesia be managed sustainably?." Land use policy 30, no. 1 (2013): 952-965.

Papillon, Martin, and Thierry Rodon. "The transformative potential of Indigenous-driven approaches to implementing free, prior and informed consent: Lessons from two Canadian cases." International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 27, no. 2 (2020): 314-335.

Pusaka. “Proyek Strategis Nasional Pengembangan Pangan dan Energi Merauke Berpotensi Melanggar Hak Asasi Manusia dan Memperparah Krisis Ekologi.” Pusaka, August 2, 2024. https://pusaka.or.id/news/proyek-strategis-nasional-pengembangan-pangan-dan-energi-merauke-berpotensi-melanggar-hak-asasi-manusia-dan-memperparah-krisis-ekologi/.

Reder, Michael, ed. Global Common Good: Intercultural Perspectives on a Just and Ecological Transformation. Campus Verlag, 2015.

Rosin, Christopher, Paul Stock, and Hugh Campbell, eds. Food systems failure: The global food crisis and the future of agriculture. Routledge, 2013.

Santosa, Edi. "Percepatan pengembangan food estate untuk meningkatkan ketahanan dan kemandirian pangan nasional." Risalah Kebijakan Pertanian dan Lingkungan Rumusan Kajian Strategis Bidang Pertanian Dan Lingkungan 1, no. 2 (2014): 80-85.

Saunders, Samira Homerang, Angela Sherwood, and David Whyte. "Autonomy over Life: The Struggle against Capitalist Development in West Papua." State Crime Journal 13, no. 2 (2024): 173-196.

Schilling-Vacaflor, Almut, and Riccarda Flemmer. "Mobilising free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) from below: A typology of indigenous peoples’ agency." International journal on minority and group rights 27, no. 2 (2020): 291-313.

Setiawan, Eko. "Konflik Pada Kawasan Konservasi Taman Nasional Alas Purwo Dan Solusi Penyelesaiannya." Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik Malikussaleh (JSPM) 3, no. 2 (2022): 286-297.

Storey, Matthew. "A Failure of Praxis: The Application of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) in the Australian Resources Sector." In The Routledge Handbook on Meaningful Stakeholder Engagement, pp. 138-147. Routledge, 2024.

Sudiarawan, Kadek Agus, Alia Yofira Karunian, Dewa Gede Sudika Mangku, and Bagus Hermanto. "Discourses on Citizen Lawsuit as Administrative Dispute Object: Government Administration Law vs. Administrative Court Law." JILS 7 (2022): 449.

Sudibyo, Lintang, and Lyn Parker. "‘Menjadi Manusia’(Becoming Somebody): The Aspirations and Realities of Marind Young People, Papua, Indonesia." Oceania 94, no. 3 (2024): 202-223.

Thontowi, Jawahir, and Sri Wartini. "Effectuating Food Sovereignty without Violating the Rights of Indigenous People: A Case Study of the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate Project." KnE Social Sciences (2023): 616-624.

Tobing, Vera Tua. "Problematic Analysis of the Legal Policy of the Food Estate Program (Government Era 2020-2024)." Journal of Law, Politic and Humanities 5, no. 2 (2024): 983-991.

Viartasiwi, Nino, Agus Trihartono, and Hary Yuswadi. "The West Papua imagined community: A bondless plural society." Sustainable Future for Human Security: Society, Cities and Governance (2018): 79-99.

Wambrauw, Elisabeth Veronika. "The Sustainability of the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate (MIFEE)." The International Journal of Environmental Sustainability 13, no. 2 (2017): 15.

Widiastuti, Maria Maghdalena Diana, Yusman Syaukat, A. Faroby Falatehan, and Dedi Budiman Hakim. "Tinjauan Implementasi Program Food Estate Dan Prospeknya Di Merauke Papua." In Forum Penelitian Agro Ekonomi 40, no. 2 (2022): 119-133.

Widyastuti, Ariyani Yakti, 2024, “List of Companies Working on Jokowi’s Merauke Food Estate Project”, Tempo, accessed on October 28, 2024, at 15:31 WIB. https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/1920768/daftar-perusahaan-penggarap-proyek-food-estate- merauke-jokowi.

Yakovleva, Natalia, T. N. Gavrilyeva, A. I. Makarov, and N. A. Krasilnikova. "Free prior informed consent in the extractive industry: Approaches to involving Indigenous peoples in decision-making in Russia." Journal of Environmental Management 344 (2023): 118341.

Yuliantika, Rizkia Diffa, Imamulhadi Imamulhadi, and Supraba Sekarwati. "Analisis Yuridis Terhadap Program Pembangunan Food Estate Di Kawasan Hutan Ditinjau Dari Eco-Justice." LITRA: Jurnal Hukum Lingkungan, Tata Ruang, Dan Agraria 2, no. 1 (2022): 41-62.

Yusup, Syamsuri, and Yoneta Sonia. "Can Rice Farming through the National Strategy Food Estate Increase Regional Production?." Jurnal Lahan Suboptimal: Journal of Suboptimal Lands 13, no. 2 (2024): 186-197.